Gospel Notes by Michael Whelan SM
When Jesus saw the crowds, he went up the mountain; and after he sat down, his disciples came to him. 2 Then he began to speak, and taught them, saying:
3 “Blessed are the poor in spirit, for theirs is the kingdom of heaven.
4 “Blessed are those who mourn, for they will be comforted.
5 “Blessed are the meek, for they will inherit the earth.
6 “Blessed are those who hunger and thirst for righteousness, for they will be filled.
7 “Blessed are the merciful, for they will receive mercy.
8 “Blessed are the pure in heart, for they will see God.
9 “Blessed are the peacemakers, for they will be called children of God.
10 “Blessed are those who are persecuted for righteousness’ sake, for theirs is the kingdom of heaven.
11 “Blessed are you when people revile you and persecute you and utter all kinds of evil against you falsely on my account. 12 Rejoice and be glad, for your reward is great in heaven, for in the same way they persecuted the prophets who were before you (Matthew 5:1-12 – NRSV).
Introductory Notes
General
The prevailing opinion amongst Scripture scholars of the New Testament is that Mark’s Gospel was the first. Matthew and Luke borrowed from Mark and each had their own oral tradition to draw on. Matthew and Luke also drew on a common third “source,” referred to as “Q” – from the German word for “source,” “Quelle.”
“The Matthean Beatitudes are an expansion of the set of four Q Beatitudes found in Luke 6:20–23. Luke expanded the set of four by constructing a corresponding set of four woes (Luke 6:24–26), whereas Matthew (or his sources) has filled out the list of Beatitudes to make nine” (Daniel J Harrington, SJ, The Gospel of Matthew, Collegeville, MIN: Liturgical Press, 2007, 82).
“Though the disciples are mentioned as constituting part of the audience (5:1), it seems that Jesus’ teaching was meant to take in all Israel being gathered by Jesus. This larger audience is suggested by the framework in which the sermon as a whole is set (4:23–25; 7:28–29). Thus the content of the sermon is not intended simply for those who are already Jesus’ disciples or for humankind in general (as if it were some kind of natural law). Rather the sermon challenges Israel to find in Jesus’ teaching the authentic interpretation of God’s will revealed in the Torah” (Ibid).
“The Beatitude form is familiar from the Hebrew Bible, especially the wisdom writings. Psalm 1 is an extended example of the Beatitude form in which someone is declared “blessed” or “happy”: “Blessed is the man who walks not in the counsel of the wicked.…” The third-person form is more common than the second person. And so Matthew’s third person reformulation of the second person Q form is consistent with the usual Jewish style for expressing a Beatitude. …”
“The most striking deviation of the nt Beatitudes from the pattern of the wisdom books comes in the timing of the reward. The assumption of the wisdom books is that virtue or good actions are rewarded in the present. The nt Beatitudes promise fullness of life in God’s kingdom. They are primarily eschatological, though there may be some anticipation of the reward in the present. When God’s kingdom comes, the kind of people who possess the virtues listed in the Beatitudes or do what they entail will be rewarded. Even those who ‘inherit the land’ (5:5) will inherit the ‘new earth’ accompanying the ‘new heaven’ when God’s kingdom comes in its fullness. Thus the Beatitudes function not as ‘entrance requirements’ but rather as a delineation of the characteristics and actions that will receive their full and appropriate eschatological reward. The promise of God’s kingdom frames the eight Beatitudes (5:3, 10), and the intervening promises (comfort, inheriting the land, satisfaction, obtaining mercy, seeing God, being called ‘sons of God’) refer to the final judgment, the vindication of the just, and the establishment of God’s perfect kingdom” (Ibid).
Specific
crowds: “The reference to the crowds at the beginning (5:1) and end (7:28–29) of the sermon provides a framework for Jesus’ teaching of Israel” (Harrington, op cit, 78).
the mountain: “By placing this first and most dramatic instance of Jesus’ teaching on the mountain, Matthew sought to evoke biblical ideas about mountains as places of divine revelation and about Mount Sinai as the place where God’s will for Israel was revealed. But note that Jesus gives the teaching; he does not receive it as Moses did” (Harrington, op cit, 82).
the poor in spirit: “Matthew’s ‘poor in spirit’ does represent, it is true,a certain ‘spiritualizing’ of Luke’s (and likely Jesus’) blunter formulation ‘Blessed are the poor’ (Luke 6:20). While the sense of economic poverty is not excluded, Matthew’s formula reflects a biblical tradition in which ‘the poor’ is an honorific name for the faithful in Israel who, conscious of lack of resources on their own part, look to YAHWEH alone for salvation” (Brendan Byrne SJ, Lifting the Burden: Reading Matthew’s Gospel in the Church Today, Collegeville, MIN: Liturgical Press, 2004, 55 Footnote 4).
Reflection from N T Wright
The worst mistake we can make about this famous and stunning passage is to see it as a list of rules (you’ve got to try hard to be poor in spirit, to mourn, to be meek, and so on). It isn’t. It’s a royal announcement that God is turning the world upside down—or, rather, the right way up.
Come with me into the crowd that has followed Jesus away from the villages and up onto the hillside. What are we hearing? What does it mean to us?
We’ve been longing for this moment, you see, but we didn’t know what it was going to be like. For generations we’ve all been taught that one day our God, the maker of heaven and earth, would come back to us and set everything right. But as time has gone on it’s looked more and more as though he’s forgotten us. Arrogant foreign soldiers have pushed their way into our land. Other nations, with their strange and lurid cultures, have taken over some of our towns and changed them into places where decent people wouldn’t want to go. And the taxes they make us pay! Anyone would think we were still slaves, instead of God’s free people.
But nobody quite knew what it would look like when God came back to us. Some people have said it would be like a great pillar of cloud and fire. Some have said he’d come riding at the head of a great army to defeat the horrible people who are making our lives miserable. Some have even said that we’d better not wait any longer, that perhaps God wants us to act first and then he’ll come and help us.
So when we heard about this prophet who was going round the villages healing people and saying that the sovereign rule of heaven was now on the way, we were really excited. What’s his plan? What’s he saying is going to happen?
And now he’s telling us that God is indeed on the move—and that people like us are going to come out on top! We’ve had our spirits crushed all right; we’ve been sorrowful, we’ve been longing for God’s way to triumph. It’s been a hunger eating away at us inside. And now he’s saying that the poor in spirit will inherit heaven’s kingdom, that the sorrowful will be comforted, that the hungry will be satisfied. All right! This is what we’ve been waiting for! But how will it happen? What do we have to do? What are his plans for making it happen?
Well, he’s saying some other things, too. He’s saying that it’s the meek who will inherit the earth—not the rich, the powerful, the violent or the pushy. Some people in the crowd don’t like that. It sounds like a cop-out to them. And he’s saying that the merciful and the peacemakers are the ones who will receive God’s mercy, who will be called God’s children (we think all the people of Israel are God’s children; it sounds as though he’s saying that God is reshaping Israel itself!). That’s not going to please those who want to fight and kill to make God’s will happen.
And then he’s saying that it’s going to be tough. People are going to hate us and persecute us. Well, we’ve had plenty of that already, so what’s new? It sounds as though he’s saying that God is doing a new thing—and that like the ancient prophets many of our own people won’t like it. He wants us to follow him, even though it’s going to be unpopular.
I don’t know where this is leading. But I’ve never heard anyone speaking like this before. It’s a whole new way of being God’s people. It’s a whole new way of being human. Well, we’ve tried everything else. Maybe, after all, this is what it’s going to look like when God comes back to rescue us. I’m ready to sign up. What about you?
Today
Lord Jesus, help us to hear your voice, to accept your challenge, and to follow you in the way of your kingdom.
(N T (“Tom”) Wright, Lent for Everyone: Matthew Year A, SPCK, 2011, 14-16).
Blessed are you
In today’s Gospel – Matthew 5:1-12 – we have perhaps the best-known and loved text from the New Testament. If the truth be told, however, few people could give you a coherent interpretation of the Beatitudes and why they are so appealing. One possibility is the very word, “Blessed.” The Greek word used in Matthew’s text is makarioi, generally meaning “fortunate” or “happy.” In this context, however, it carries with it the affirmation of God’s loving choice. The word reiterates and confirms the great promise of Sinai: “I am with you!” (Exodus 3:12). Thus, Jesus speaks the word as “‘Emmanuel’ which means ‘God is with us’” (1:23). The very heart of the Incarnation is being expressed here – Jesus speaks as one who knows firsthand the experience of human suffering and our need to hear the affirmation of love at such times. The words of the prophet Isaiah come to mind: “I have called you by name, you are mine” (43:1).
The “kingdom of heaven” will not be just another version – albeit a more enjoyable version – of the “kingdoms of the world” (4:8). The “kingdom of heaven” is a radically new way of being. It begins now in Jesus. Through him, with him and in him, we move towards its completion. On the way, this radically new way of being will sometimes have us in conflict with the way of being of the “kingdoms of the world.” At all times, especially in those times of suffering, we must remember we are “blessed.”
Jesus is not presenting a moral project as if, by choosing to be poor, meek, in mourning, hungering and thirsting for righteousness etc, we will be rewarded by being “blessed.” Is there a moral vision here and a likely moral outcome? Most definitely! Being blessed implies the gifts of faith, hope and love. The gift of faith enables us to recognize Jesus as the embodiment of God’s love; the gift of hope enables us to recognize that, in Jesus, good will triumph over evil in the end; the gift of love enables us to be the bodily presence of God for the people, events and things of this world. Knowing we are blessed transforms us, even if the circumstances in which we find ourselves remain painful.
Both the blessing and the knowing we are blessed are works of grace. To the poor, the meek, those in mourning , those who hunger and thirst for righteousness, Jesus says: “Do not ever forget you are blessed!” To all his disciples, then and now, Jesus says: “Do not ever forget, you are blessed!” In the dark it is so easy to forget what we saw so clearly in the light. Recognizing we are blessed reminds us of the ground on which we stand and from which we grow.
Recall the Blessing Prayer in the Eucharistic celebration: “Blessed are you Lord God of all creation, through your goodness etc.” How might you, personally, finish that prayer?
